Zane Minder
3/19/13
Begert
English 101
Over the past decades the United States has fallen behind many other developed nations in the rankings of educational systems. The United States of America, one of the great economic and political powers of the world, has long struggled to find a solution to its educational problems. There are many reasons that the system in America is failing but it seems to me that the real problem lies with the teachers. Quality teachers can have an enormous impact on a student’s educations and on their life, but teachers that have the knowledge and strong passion for teaching are often difficult to come by. The most important change that needs to be made in k-12 education is creating a system that is more appealing to quality teachers.
Boredom seems to be the most popular feeling when it comes to kids in school. In his essay, “Against School”, John Gatto found that teachers were also bored, blaming the students who were rude and at most, just interested in getting a good grade. The students are bored with the structured curriculum that allows less originality and creativity in United States Schools and so are the teachers. Giving teacher’s more freedom in the class room may be a good way to change the view that kids and educators have on school by introducing more original ideas to get interest of the students. An example of a good teacher gaining the interest and respect from his students is Mr. Escalante in the film Stand and Deliver. When his students from an underfunded, inner city Los Angeles math class show little interest in story problems, he uses examples that the students find humorous in order to get the students interested in the subject. In his article, "Children, Arts, and Du Bois", Keith Gilyard visits an after school program for urban public school students and was delighted to see "such creative energy on display in that environment." The Program that he visited allowed students to create poetry, lyrics, songs, and dance. This kind of originality and freedom is occurring less in schools because the teachers are forced to follow a strictly structured curriculum. Another program that has shown student success in a creative atmosphere is the Mexican American Studies program in the Tuscan Unified School District. There is support that the program has been successful because “Ninety-seven percent of students participating in the program graduated from high school, compared to 44 percent nationally. Students scored higher on the AIMS (Arizona Instrument to Measure Standards) test compared to other Hispanic students who did not take the classes.” (Aronson) Curtis Acosta, a Teacher involved in the program, believes “Everyone that has been in these spaces has left totally inspired by our students and the work we’re doing,” (Aronson) These creative environments are very helpful in developing students and providing them with a well-rounded education. By giving teachers more freedom in the classroom school systems can combat student, as well as teacher boredom alike.
Another way to make the educational system appeal to teachers is a large factor in many people's lives, money. The average high school teacher in the United States earns between thirty thousand and fifty thousand dollars per year, compared to a doctor, who earns an average of one hundred and forty thousand dollars per year. If the United States wants to create an educational system that provides students with teachers that are going to perform at a high level we need to increase teacher salaries in order to make being a teacher more appealing financially. In his video on education, Lewis Black argues that schools don't need to be the most beautiful buildings in the world. Although visually appealing and expensive school buildings can be more welcoming to students and teachers, they aren't nearly as valuable as quality teachers in terms of student success. It seems that reducing spending on the building itself and providing more incentives for teachers that perform at a high level would be a smarter alternative. Adding more incentives for teachers could make the career more competitive when they have the opportunity to earn more money based on their performance instead of a salary with occasional raises.
Another change that could help education in America is refining the tenure system. Tenure was meant to protect professors in universities from being fired for political reasons. In Illinois only "...1 in 57 doctors loses his or her medical license, and 1 in 97 attorneys loses his or her law license, but only 1 teacher in 2500 has ever lost his or her credentials." (Waiting for Superman) After watching Waiting for 'Superman', I found that I was angry about the tenure system in public schools. Tenured teachers who have been teaching at a low level for a long period of time are getting seniority and are less likely to get fired or laid off than newer teachers that are performing at a high level. Tenured teachers may lose the motivation to teach when they don't have to worry about getting fired for poor performance. In the film a student brought in a camera to capture the poor performance of tenured teachers. The camera caught several teachers at their desk reading the newspaper quietly or doing crosswords while the students in the classroom did whatever they wanted in a chaotic mess. I believe public schools should remove tenure entirely or at least reform the system to avoid teachers that take advantage of it causing the students to receive a poor education.
In order to get the qualified and motivated teachers for public schools in the United States, we have to make teaching a more enjoyable occupation. By allowing freedom in the classroom schools can be more efficient by allowing creativity to get students involved and interested in learning and becoming educated. With a restructuring of the tenure system quality teachers will have more opportunities to teach at a high level instead of keeping tenured teachers that have lost the motivation to teach effectively. I addition, offering teachers more competitive salaries and performance based incentive plans will hopefully give more students a better chance at a quality education in the United States.
Stand and Deliver. Dir. Ramon Menendez. Perf. Edward James Olmos, Estelle Harris, Mark Phelan, Virginia Paris. Warner Bros, 1988. Film.
Chalk. Dir. Mike Akel. Perf. Mike Akel, Angie Alvarez, Graham Davidson, Chris Mass, Michael McAlister. Virgil Films, 2007. Film.
Black, Lewis."Daily Show: Back in Black:Education Crisis | MilkandCookies."
MilkandCookies. N.p., n.d. Web. 19 Mar. 2013.
http://www.milkandcookies.com/link/223041/detail/>.
Gatto, John. "Against School." Harpers 1 (2003): 5. Print.
Waiting for 'Superman'. Dir. Davis Guggenheim. Perf. . . Paramount Home
Entertainment, 2011. DVD.
Gilyard, Keith. "Children, Arts, and Du Bois." President's Commentary 1 (2012): 2. Print.
Aronson, Deb. "Arizona Bans Mexican American Studies Program." National Council of Teachers of English September 2012: 21-23. Print.
Chalk. Dir. Mike Akel. Perf. Mike Akel, Angie Alvarez, Graham Davidson, Chris Mass, Michael McAlister. Virgil Films, 2007. Film.
Black, Lewis."Daily Show: Back in Black:Education Crisis | MilkandCookies."
MilkandCookies. N.p., n.d. Web. 19 Mar. 2013.
http://www.milkandcookies.com/link/223041/detail/>.
Gatto, John. "Against School." Harpers 1 (2003): 5. Print.
Waiting for 'Superman'. Dir. Davis Guggenheim. Perf. . . Paramount Home
Entertainment, 2011. DVD.
Gilyard, Keith. "Children, Arts, and Du Bois." President's Commentary 1 (2012): 2. Print.
Aronson, Deb. "Arizona Bans Mexican American Studies Program." National Council of Teachers of English September 2012: 21-23. Print.