Tuesday, March 19, 2013

Paper 3 Final Draft

Zane Minder

3/19/13

Begert

English 101





Over the past decades the United States has fallen behind many other developed nations in the rankings of educational systems. The United States of America, one of the great economic and political powers of the world, has long struggled to find a solution to its educational problems. There are many reasons that the system in America is failing but it seems to me that the real problem lies with the teachers. Quality teachers can have an enormous impact on a student’s educations and on their life, but teachers that have the knowledge and strong passion for teaching are often difficult to come by. The most important change that needs to be made in k-12 education is creating a system that is more appealing to quality teachers.

Boredom seems to be the most popular feeling when it comes to kids in school. In his essay, “Against School”, John Gatto found that teachers were also bored, blaming the students who were rude and at most, just interested in getting a good grade. The students are bored with the structured curriculum that allows less originality and creativity in United States Schools and so are the teachers. Giving teacher’s more freedom in the class room may be a good way to change the view that kids and educators have on school by introducing more original ideas to get interest of the students. An example of a good teacher gaining the interest and respect from his students is Mr. Escalante in the film Stand and Deliver. When his students from an underfunded, inner city Los Angeles math class show little interest in story problems, he uses examples that the students find humorous in order to get the students interested in the subject. In his article, "Children, Arts, and Du Bois", Keith Gilyard visits an after school program for urban public school students and was delighted to see "such creative energy on display in that environment." The Program that he visited allowed students to create poetry, lyrics, songs, and dance. This kind of originality and freedom is occurring less in schools because the teachers are forced to follow a strictly structured curriculum. Another program that has shown student success in a creative atmosphere is the Mexican American Studies program in the Tuscan Unified School District. There is support that the program has been successful because “Ninety-seven percent of students participating in the program graduated from high school, compared to 44 percent nationally. Students scored higher on the AIMS (Arizona Instrument to Measure Standards) test compared to other Hispanic students who did not take the classes.” (Aronson) Curtis Acosta, a Teacher involved in the program, believes “Everyone that has been in these spaces has left totally inspired by our students and the work we’re doing,” (Aronson) These creative environments are very helpful in developing students and providing them with a well-rounded education. By giving teachers more freedom in the classroom school systems can combat student, as well as teacher boredom alike.

Another way to make the educational system appeal to teachers is a large factor in many people's lives, money. The average high school teacher in the United States earns between thirty thousand and fifty thousand dollars per year, compared to a doctor, who earns an average of one hundred and forty thousand dollars per year. If the United States wants to create an educational system that provides students with teachers that are going to perform at a high level we need to increase teacher salaries in order to make being a teacher more appealing financially. In his video on education, Lewis Black argues that schools don't need to be the most beautiful buildings in the world. Although visually appealing and expensive school buildings can be more welcoming to students and teachers, they aren't nearly as valuable as quality teachers in terms of student success. It seems that reducing spending on the building itself and providing more incentives for teachers that perform at a high level would be a smarter alternative. Adding more incentives for teachers could make the career more competitive when they have the opportunity to earn more money based on their performance instead of a salary with occasional raises.
           
Another change that could help education in America is refining the tenure system. Tenure was meant to protect professors in universities from being fired for political reasons. In Illinois only "...1 in 57 doctors loses his or her medical license, and 1 in 97 attorneys loses his or her law license, but only 1 teacher in 2500 has ever lost his or her credentials." (Waiting for Superman) After watching Waiting for 'Superman', I found that I was angry about the tenure system in public schools.  Tenured teachers who have been teaching at a low level for a long period of time are getting seniority and are less likely to get fired or laid off than newer teachers that are performing at a high level. Tenured teachers may lose the motivation to teach when they don't have to worry about getting fired for poor performance. In the film a student brought in a camera to capture the poor performance of tenured teachers. The camera caught several teachers at their desk reading the newspaper quietly or doing crosswords while the students in the classroom did whatever they wanted in a chaotic mess. I believe public schools should remove tenure entirely or at least reform the system to avoid teachers that take advantage of it causing the students to receive a poor education.

In order to get the qualified and motivated teachers for public schools in the United States, we have to make teaching a more enjoyable occupation. By allowing freedom in the classroom schools can be more efficient by allowing creativity to get students involved and interested in learning and becoming educated. With a restructuring of the tenure system quality teachers will have more opportunities to teach at a high level instead of keeping tenured teachers that have lost the motivation to teach effectively. I addition, offering teachers more competitive salaries and performance based incentive plans will hopefully give more students a better chance at a quality education in the United States.




Stand and Deliver. Dir. Ramon Menendez. Perf. Edward James Olmos, Estelle Harris, Mark Phelan, Virginia Paris. Warner Bros, 1988. Film.

Chalk. Dir. Mike Akel. Perf. Mike Akel, Angie Alvarez, Graham Davidson, Chris Mass, Michael McAlister. Virgil Films, 2007. Film.


Black, Lewis."Daily Show: Back in Black:Education Crisis | MilkandCookies."
MilkandCookies. N.p., n.d. Web. 19 Mar. 2013.
http://www.milkandcookies.com/link/223041/detail/>.

Gatto, John. "Against School." Harpers 1 (2003): 5. Print.

Waiting for 'Superman'. Dir. Davis Guggenheim. Perf. . . Paramount Home
Entertainment, 2011. DVD.

Gilyard, Keith. "Children, Arts, and Du Bois." President's Commentary 1 (2012): 2. Print.

Aronson, Deb. "Arizona Bans Mexican American Studies Program." National Council of Teachers of English September 2012: 21-23. Print.

Paper 3 Rough Draft


 Over the past decades the United States has fallen behind many other developed nations in the rankings of educational systems.   The United States of America, one of the great economic and political powers of the world, has long struggled to find a solution to its educational problems. There are many reasons that the system in America is failing but it seems to me that the real problem lies with the teachers. Quality teachers can have an enormous impact on a student’s educations  and on their life, but teachers with that have the knowledge and strong passion for teaching are often difficult to come by. The most  important  change  that  needs to be made in k-12 education is creating a system that is more appealing to quality teachers.

Boredom seems to be the most popular feeling when it comes to kids in school. In his essay, “Against School”, John Gatto found that teachers were also bored, blaming the students who were rude and at most, just interested in getting a good grade. The students are bored with the structured curriculum that allows less originality and creativity in United States Schools and so are the teachers. Giving teacher’s more freedom in the class room may be a good way to change the view that kids and educators have on school by introducing more original ideas to get interest of the students. An example of a good teacher gaining the interest and respect from his students is Mr. Escalante in the film Stand and Deliver. When his students from an underfunded, inner city Los Angeles math class show little interest in story problems, he uses examples that the students find humorous in order to get the students interested in the subject.

The average high school teacher in the United States earns between Thirty Thousand and Fifty Thousand dollars per year, compared to a doctor, who earns an average of One Hundred and Forty Thousand dollars per year. If the United States wants to create an educational system that provides students with teachers that are going to perform at a high level they need to increase teacher salaries in order to make being a teacher more appealing financially. In his video on education, Lewis Black argues that schools don't need to be the most beautiful buildings in the world. Although visually appealing an expensive school building can be more welcoming to students and teachers, they aren't nearly as valuable as quality teachers in terms of student success. It seems to me that reducing spending on the building itself and providing more incentives for teachers that perform at a high level would be a smarter alternative. Adding more incentives for teachers could make the career more competitive when they have the opportunity to earn more money based on their performance.
            Another change that could help education in America is refining the tenure system. Tenure was meant to protect professors in universities from being fired for political reasons. After watching Waiting for 'Superman', I found that I was angry about the tenure system in public schools.  Tenured teachers who have been teaching at a low level for a long period of time are getting seniority and are less likely to get fired than newer teachers that are performing at a high level. Tenured teachers may lose the motivation to teach when they don't have to worry about getting fired for poor performance. In the film a student brought in a camera to capture the poor performance of tenured teachers. The camera caught several teachers at their desk reading the newspaper quietly or doing crosswords while the students in the classroom did whatever they wanted in a chaotic mess. I believe public schools should remove tenure entirely to avoid teachers that take advantage of it causing the students to receive a poor education.


Stand and Deliver. Dir. Ramon Menendez. Perf. Edward James Olmos, Estelle Harris, Mark Phelan, Virginia Paris. Warner Bros, 1988. Film.

Chalk. Dir. Mike Akel. Perf. Mike Akel, Angie Alvarez, Graham Davidson, Chris Mass, Michael McAlister. Virgil Films, 2007. Film.

Sunday, March 17, 2013

Gilyard and NEA

When Gilyard visits the after school program for urban public school students he is glad to see "such creative energy on display in that environment." The Program allowed students to create poetry, lyrics, songs, and dance. Shortly after his visit, Gilyard learned that this stimulating and creative program would most likely be shut down due to lack of funds. Gilyard fears that the students are doomed without this creative art environment because they are much better off in the afternoon programs than they are without them.
In the Tuscan Unified School District ninety-seven percent of students that participated in the Mexican American Studies program  graduated from high school compared to fourty-four percent nationally. Even though the program was having success, it was shut down because according to some politicians and the State Superintendent of Public instruction said the program "promoted resentment of mainstream culture."
These articles are important to our current unit because these programs that allow students to think freely are dying with budget cuts because they aren't seen as important as subjects such as math. These subjects promote creativity are important to developing well rounded students and are important to giving students a complete education. 

Gatto "Against School"

Boredom seems to be the most popular feeling when it comes to kids in school. Gatto found that teachers were also bored, blaming the students who where rude and at most, just interested in getting a good grade. Gatto goes on to tell how his grandfather had taught him never to use the word bored in his presence because "if I was bored it was my fault and no one else's" This is the absolute truth. Everyone has the power to cure their boredom but it takes effort. If you don't put in the effort you're going to be bored. Gatto believes that breaking down the structure in schools is beneficial for students to gain experience and an education rather that just a "schooling". Going to school and getting good grades is great, but you need to look at the big picture and learn, as in retain the knowledge or skill so you can use it in the future.
Gatto ends the article by saying, "After a long life, and thirty years in the public school trenches, I've concluded that genius is as common as dirt. We suppress our genius only because we haven't yet figured out how to manage a population of educated men and women. the solution, I think, is simple and glorious. Let them manage themselves." This seems like a great idea, but the missing piece might be effort. To make this work the students need to be willing to put in the effort and have enough curiosity to make things happen.

Mike Rose And Lewis Black

In his video on education, Lewis Black argues that schools don't need to be the most beautiful building in the world. Although visually appealing and expensive school buildings are can be more welcoming to students and teachers, they aren't nearly as valuable as quality teachers in terms of student success. It seems to me that reducing spending on the building itself and providing more incentives for teachers that perform at a high level would be a smarter alternative. Adding more incentives for teachers could make the career more competitive, in theory boosting performance.

In Mike Rose's "Resolutions Someone Should make for 2011", his fourth resolution urges to" stop making the standardized test score the gold-standard of student achievement and teacher effectiveness. In what other profession do we use a single metric to judge goodness?" The goal of education should oriented towards preparing students for life, whether it be college or the workforce, students should be able to retain skills in school that benefit them when they are out of school. Not everyone goes to college. Those who don't need to have some sort of skill set that can be applied to the outside world.

Tuesday, March 12, 2013

Waiting For Superman- notes

-the education of students that can't afford private schools is based on luck that they will attend a good public school

-although the funding per student has doubled in the united states since 1971, the results of students test scores have remained the same.

-Daisy's parent both dropped out of school because their family's needed additional income in the house to afford to eat

-failing elementary and middle schools feed high schools that have to highest drop out rates. called drop out factories

-68% of inmates in penn. are high school drop outs

-standards of education vary greatly from state to state

-tenure is almost automatic in public schools after years of teaching. when a teacher is granted tenure it is very difficult for them to get fired so they can lose the motivation to teach

-performance should be the deciding factor in teacher layoffs instead of the seniority of teachers that have been peforming at a lower level for a longer period of time.

-by law, charter schools with more applicants than openings need to select students by lottery



After watching Waiting for 'Superman',  I found that I was angry about the tenure system in public schools.  Tenured teachers who have been teaching at a low level for a long period of time are getting senority and are less likely to get fired than newer teachers that are performing at a high level. Tenured teachers may lose the motivation to teach when they don't have to worry about getting fired for poor performance.

Tuesday, March 5, 2013

"Chalk" Notes

-Mr. stroope tries to using humor to get his students involved and asks the students what they did in the summer.
      -Mr. Stroope holds his students after class because they are using words that he doesn't understand and admits that they probably know more about the subject than he does.
     -makes a fake phone call to a student's father as a threat for him to stop showing him up in class because the student knows more about the subject.
      -His goal to become teacher of the year seems to be the most important thing to him
      -he is so upset that he doesn't win teacher of the year that it effects his actions in class. he loses interest in teaching and flips a desk in anger.



- Coach Webb struggles to get her students to take her PE class seriously. She also feels that people assume that she is gay because she has short hair and is a PE teacher.
       -she feels that other teachers are not enforcing the rules when students are late to class and she wants them to be punished because it is not fair to the students who are on time.
       -


-Mr. Lowry seems very self conscious in his first day as a teacher. He doesn't seem confident on his first day of teaching. when his student asks how long he has been teaching, he tries to dance around the question until admitting that he has been teaching for about and hour.

       -Mr. Lowry quickly loses control of his class room when he has his students free write. The class is loud and chaotic and he threatens to give his student a referral. Two of his students get in an a argument and he struggles to break them apart. He gets little or no respect from his students and appears frustrated and exhausted.
              - Fellow teachers are also eating his yogurt when he puts his name on it. showing they don't have respect for him either.
              -His students hide his chalk from him and continue to disrespect him as they all laugh in class.
             -the students don't feel like they need to learn his lessons.
             -Mr. Lowry decides to use more humor in class to get the interest of his students
             -Mr. Lowry is becoming very stressed

-Mrs. Redell misses teaching and misses the students that really care and want to learn.



This film helps share education from the teacher's perspective.